Is It Cake? poster

Season 2 - Best Episodes Of Is It Cake?

Overall Rating: ★ 6.0

Season 2 - Best Episodes Of Is It Cake?

(Overall Rating: ★ 6.0)

Episode Ratings & Analysis

Explore season 2 episodes of Is It Cake?. Explore detailed ratings, episode summaries, and visualize how the show's quality evolved over time.

Skilled cake artists create mouthwatering replicas of handbags, sewing machines and more in a mind-bending baking contest inspired by a popular meme.

3 Seasons
24 Episodes
Returning Series
Reality
Best Episodes
S2E1 - Everything Is Cake! ★ 6.8
S2E8 - Winner Cakes All! ★ 6.8
S2E2 - Body by Cake ★ 6.6
Worst Episodes
S2E3 - Cake University ★ 5.1
S2E7 - Cake Me Out to the Ballgame ★ 6.0
S2E4 - That 90's Cake ★ 6.4
★ 6.8/10 (94 votes)
#1

Everything Is Cake!

S2:E1

The bakers dig deep to craft incredible, edible objects with personal significance. Guest judges: Chrishell Stause, Blake Anderson and Maz Jobrani.

izzmo Jul 1, 2023

Flipped the scrip this season! Should make the season more interesting and fun to watch without dull...

★ 6.8/10 (46 votes)
#2

Winner Cakes All!

S2:E8

With $75,000 on the line, the three remaining bakers face a final full of surprises. Guest judges: Jade Catta-Preta, Chris Redd and Taylor Tomlinson.

Sopherian Jul 31, 2024

Looking back at the entire season... Hell yea! Well deserved

★ 6.6/10 (73 votes)
#3

Body by Cake

S2:E2

A gym-themed challenge finds the cake artists scrambling to imitate exercise equipment. Guest judges: Nico Santos, Joel McHale and Ally Love.

jcpdiesel21 Jul 27, 2023

I wish Joel McHale could be a judge in every episode.

★ 6.6/10 (41 votes)
#4

So Fresh and So Cake

S2:E6

From frosted toilets to fondant toothpaste: Will a bathroom theme send the bakers' dreams down the drain? Guest judges: Charli, Heidi and Dixie D’Amelio.

★ 6.5/10 (39 votes)
#5

S'more Cake Please

S2:E5

Bakers re-create the great outdoors with realistic cakes inspired by camping gear. Guest judges: Brandon Kyle Goodman, Cristela Alonzo and Kate Flannery.

Mogregio Jul 5, 2023

It's getting ridiculous with judges not locking in and the bakers sabotaging the decoys, totally des...

★ 6.4/10 (52 votes)
#6

That 90's Cake

S2:E4

A retro challenge takes contestants back to the '90s with VCRs, Dr. Martens and more. Guest judges: Anna Camp, Melissa Villaseñor and Joel Kim Booster.

jcpdiesel21 Jul 30, 2023

Again with the cheating! I really don't like the contestants futzing with the decoys. Hopefully th...

★ 6.0/10 (46 votes)
#7

Cake Me Out to the Ballgame

S2:E7

A stressful semifinal brings sports-themed cakes — and a high-stakes double elimination. Game on! Guest judges: Jeff Dye, Chiney Ogwumike and Flula Borg.

Sopherian Jul 31, 2024

Come on.... You could see Spirit her cake from miles away! I don't believe it lol

★ 5.1/10 (87 votes)
#8

Cake University

S2:E3

School's in session with A+ cakes that look like they came from a college dorm. Guest judges: Chris Witaske, Kirby Howell-Baptiste and Chloe Fineman.

Atlantis14 Jul 13, 2023

Seems the bakers are not as good as the first season. They didn't touch the real objects before. Tha...

★ 5.1/10 (87 votes)
#1

Cake University

S2:E3

School's in session with A+ cakes that look like they came from a college dorm. Guest judges: Chris Witaske, Kirby Howell-Baptiste and Chloe Fineman.

Atlantis14 Jul 13, 2023

Seems the bakers are not as good as the first season. They didn't touch the real objects before. Tha...

★ 6.0/10 (46 votes)
#2

Cake Me Out to the Ballgame

S2:E7

A stressful semifinal brings sports-themed cakes — and a high-stakes double elimination. Game on! Guest judges: Jeff Dye, Chiney Ogwumike and Flula Borg.

Sopherian Jul 31, 2024

Come on.... You could see Spirit her cake from miles away! I don't believe it lol

★ 6.4/10 (52 votes)
#3

That 90's Cake

S2:E4

A retro challenge takes contestants back to the '90s with VCRs, Dr. Martens and more. Guest judges: Anna Camp, Melissa Villaseñor and Joel Kim Booster.

jcpdiesel21 Jul 30, 2023

Again with the cheating! I really don't like the contestants futzing with the decoys. Hopefully th...

★ 6.5/10 (39 votes)
#4

S'more Cake Please

S2:E5

Bakers re-create the great outdoors with realistic cakes inspired by camping gear. Guest judges: Brandon Kyle Goodman, Cristela Alonzo and Kate Flannery.

Mogregio Jul 5, 2023

It's getting ridiculous with judges not locking in and the bakers sabotaging the decoys, totally des...

★ 6.6/10 (73 votes)
#5

Body by Cake

S2:E2

A gym-themed challenge finds the cake artists scrambling to imitate exercise equipment. Guest judges: Nico Santos, Joel McHale and Ally Love.

jcpdiesel21 Jul 27, 2023

I wish Joel McHale could be a judge in every episode.

★ 6.6/10 (41 votes)
#6

So Fresh and So Cake

S2:E6

From frosted toilets to fondant toothpaste: Will a bathroom theme send the bakers' dreams down the drain? Guest judges: Charli, Heidi and Dixie D’Amelio.

★ 6.8/10 (94 votes)
#7

Everything Is Cake!

S2:E1

The bakers dig deep to craft incredible, edible objects with personal significance. Guest judges: Chrishell Stause, Blake Anderson and Maz Jobrani.

izzmo Jul 1, 2023

Flipped the scrip this season! Should make the season more interesting and fun to watch without dull...

★ 6.8/10 (46 votes)
#8

Winner Cakes All!

S2:E8

With $75,000 on the line, the three remaining bakers face a final full of surprises. Guest judges: Jade Catta-Preta, Chris Redd and Taylor Tomlinson.

Sopherian Jul 31, 2024

Looking back at the entire season... Hell yea! Well deserved

★ 6.8/10 (94 votes)

Everything Is Cake!

S2:E1

The bakers dig deep to craft incredible, edible objects with personal significance. Guest judges: Chrishell Stause, Blake Anderson and Maz Jobrani.

izzmo Jul 1, 2023

Flipped the scrip this season! Should make the season more interesting and fun to watch without dull...

★ 6.6/10 (73 votes)

Body by Cake

S2:E2

A gym-themed challenge finds the cake artists scrambling to imitate exercise equipment. Guest judges: Nico Santos, Joel McHale and Ally Love.

jcpdiesel21 Jul 27, 2023

I wish Joel McHale could be a judge in every episode.

★ 5.1/10 (87 votes)

Cake University

S2:E3

School's in session with A+ cakes that look like they came from a college dorm. Guest judges: Chris Witaske, Kirby Howell-Baptiste and Chloe Fineman.

Atlantis14 Jul 13, 2023

Seems the bakers are not as good as the first season. They didn't touch the real objects before. Tha...

★ 6.4/10 (52 votes)

That 90's Cake

S2:E4

A retro challenge takes contestants back to the '90s with VCRs, Dr. Martens and more. Guest judges: Anna Camp, Melissa Villaseñor and Joel Kim Booster.

jcpdiesel21 Jul 30, 2023

Again with the cheating! I really don't like the contestants futzing with the decoys. Hopefully th...

★ 6.5/10 (39 votes)

S'more Cake Please

S2:E5

Bakers re-create the great outdoors with realistic cakes inspired by camping gear. Guest judges: Brandon Kyle Goodman, Cristela Alonzo and Kate Flannery.

Mogregio Jul 5, 2023

It's getting ridiculous with judges not locking in and the bakers sabotaging the decoys, totally des...

★ 6.6/10 (41 votes)

So Fresh and So Cake

S2:E6

From frosted toilets to fondant toothpaste: Will a bathroom theme send the bakers' dreams down the drain? Guest judges: Charli, Heidi and Dixie D’Amelio.

★ 6.0/10 (46 votes)

Cake Me Out to the Ballgame

S2:E7

A stressful semifinal brings sports-themed cakes — and a high-stakes double elimination. Game on! Guest judges: Jeff Dye, Chiney Ogwumike and Flula Borg.

Sopherian Jul 31, 2024

Come on.... You could see Spirit her cake from miles away! I don't believe it lol

★ 6.8/10 (46 votes)

Winner Cakes All!

S2:E8

With $75,000 on the line, the three remaining bakers face a final full of surprises. Guest judges: Jade Catta-Preta, Chris Redd and Taylor Tomlinson.

Sopherian Jul 31, 2024

Looking back at the entire season... Hell yea! Well deserved

Season Average Rating Episodes Best Episode Worst Episode
1 ★ 6.6 8
★ 7.0 Winner Fakes All!
★ 6.0 Fast-Food Fakeout
2 ★ 6.3 8
★ 6.8 Everything Is Cake!
★ 5.1 Cake University
Mikey Day
Cast & Crew

View all 1 cast members and crew