Is It Cake? poster

Season 1 - Best Episodes Of Is It Cake?

Overall Rating: ★ 6.0

Season 1 - Best Episodes Of Is It Cake?

(Overall Rating: ★ 6.0)

Episode Ratings & Analysis

Explore season 1 episodes of Is It Cake?. Explore detailed ratings, episode summaries, and visualize how the show's quality evolved over time.

Skilled cake artists create mouthwatering replicas of handbags, sewing machines and more in a mind-bending baking contest inspired by a popular meme.

3 Seasons
24 Episodes
Returning Series
Reality
Best Episodes
S1E8 - Winner Fakes All! ★ 7.0
S1E4 - Imposter in Aisle 5 ★ 6.8
S1E7 - Toying Around ★ 6.7
Worst Episodes
S1E1 - Fast-Food Fakeout ★ 6.0
S1E2 - Phony Fashion ★ 6.3
S1E3 - Fake by the Ocean ★ 6.5
★ 7.0/10 (135 votes)
#1

Winner Fakes All!

S1:E8

The top three contenders design the cakes of their dreams for a shot at a $50,000 prize. Guest judges: Loni Love, Bobby Moynihan and Karamo Brown.

KatWaterflame Apr 5, 2022

Yay! The person I hoped would win was the one who won!

★ 6.8/10 (136 votes)
#2

Imposter in Aisle 5

S1:E4

Veggies, challah and cellophane-wrapped steak? Groceries never tasted so sweet. Guest judges: Courtney Parchman, Finesse Mitchell and Farley Elliott.

★ 6.7/10 (114 votes)
#3

Toying Around

S1:E7

It's time for the bakers to create cakes that look like toys. Let the games begin! Guest judges: Brittany Broski, Heidi Gardner and Dan Ahdoot.

★ 6.6/10 (121 votes)
#4

Garage Mirage

S1:E6

Cake takes the form of garage sale scores, including a bowling pin and an antique radio. Guest judges: Tony Rock, King Princess and Lyric Lewis.

★ 6.5/10 (143 votes)
#5

Fake by the Ocean

S1:E3

Clever contestants camouflage their cakes to look like things you'd see at the beach. Guest judges: Camille Kostek, Chris Witaske and Kellee Edwards.

★ 6.5/10 (130 votes)
#6

Cake Crashers

S1:E5

Remarkable cake art mimics items you'd find at a party like red Solo cups and salty snacks. Guest judges: Arthuro Castro, Rebecca Black and Jon Gabrus.

jcpdiesel21 Apr 4, 2022

I loved the fake Aight ad, but fail to understand the judges' reasoning in picking this particular w...

★ 6.3/10 (158 votes)
#7

Phony Fashion

S1:E2

Bakers create delicious decoys of shoes, designer bags and other department store finds. Guest judges: Hester Sunshine, Jason Bolden and Michael Yo.

★ 6.0/10 (236 votes)
#8

Fast-Food Fakeout

S1:E1

Flavorful cakes pose as fast-food favorites like burgers, tacos and breakfast sandwiches. Guest judges: Daym Drops, Fortune Feimster and Ronnie Woo.

poppl Mar 23, 2022

I mean, don't get me wrong, the cakes look amazing (props to the bakers!), but after one episode it ...

★ 6.0/10 (236 votes)
#1

Fast-Food Fakeout

S1:E1

Flavorful cakes pose as fast-food favorites like burgers, tacos and breakfast sandwiches. Guest judges: Daym Drops, Fortune Feimster and Ronnie Woo.

poppl Mar 23, 2022

I mean, don't get me wrong, the cakes look amazing (props to the bakers!), but after one episode it ...

★ 6.3/10 (158 votes)
#2

Phony Fashion

S1:E2

Bakers create delicious decoys of shoes, designer bags and other department store finds. Guest judges: Hester Sunshine, Jason Bolden and Michael Yo.

★ 6.5/10 (143 votes)
#3

Fake by the Ocean

S1:E3

Clever contestants camouflage their cakes to look like things you'd see at the beach. Guest judges: Camille Kostek, Chris Witaske and Kellee Edwards.

★ 6.5/10 (130 votes)
#4

Cake Crashers

S1:E5

Remarkable cake art mimics items you'd find at a party like red Solo cups and salty snacks. Guest judges: Arthuro Castro, Rebecca Black and Jon Gabrus.

jcpdiesel21 Apr 4, 2022

I loved the fake Aight ad, but fail to understand the judges' reasoning in picking this particular w...

★ 6.6/10 (121 votes)
#5

Garage Mirage

S1:E6

Cake takes the form of garage sale scores, including a bowling pin and an antique radio. Guest judges: Tony Rock, King Princess and Lyric Lewis.

★ 6.7/10 (114 votes)
#6

Toying Around

S1:E7

It's time for the bakers to create cakes that look like toys. Let the games begin! Guest judges: Brittany Broski, Heidi Gardner and Dan Ahdoot.

★ 6.8/10 (136 votes)
#7

Imposter in Aisle 5

S1:E4

Veggies, challah and cellophane-wrapped steak? Groceries never tasted so sweet. Guest judges: Courtney Parchman, Finesse Mitchell and Farley Elliott.

★ 7.0/10 (135 votes)
#8

Winner Fakes All!

S1:E8

The top three contenders design the cakes of their dreams for a shot at a $50,000 prize. Guest judges: Loni Love, Bobby Moynihan and Karamo Brown.

KatWaterflame Apr 5, 2022

Yay! The person I hoped would win was the one who won!

★ 6.0/10 (236 votes)

Fast-Food Fakeout

S1:E1

Flavorful cakes pose as fast-food favorites like burgers, tacos and breakfast sandwiches. Guest judges: Daym Drops, Fortune Feimster and Ronnie Woo.

poppl Mar 23, 2022

I mean, don't get me wrong, the cakes look amazing (props to the bakers!), but after one episode it ...

★ 6.3/10 (158 votes)

Phony Fashion

S1:E2

Bakers create delicious decoys of shoes, designer bags and other department store finds. Guest judges: Hester Sunshine, Jason Bolden and Michael Yo.

★ 6.5/10 (143 votes)

Fake by the Ocean

S1:E3

Clever contestants camouflage their cakes to look like things you'd see at the beach. Guest judges: Camille Kostek, Chris Witaske and Kellee Edwards.

★ 6.8/10 (136 votes)

Imposter in Aisle 5

S1:E4

Veggies, challah and cellophane-wrapped steak? Groceries never tasted so sweet. Guest judges: Courtney Parchman, Finesse Mitchell and Farley Elliott.

★ 6.5/10 (130 votes)

Cake Crashers

S1:E5

Remarkable cake art mimics items you'd find at a party like red Solo cups and salty snacks. Guest judges: Arthuro Castro, Rebecca Black and Jon Gabrus.

jcpdiesel21 Apr 4, 2022

I loved the fake Aight ad, but fail to understand the judges' reasoning in picking this particular w...

★ 6.6/10 (121 votes)

Garage Mirage

S1:E6

Cake takes the form of garage sale scores, including a bowling pin and an antique radio. Guest judges: Tony Rock, King Princess and Lyric Lewis.

★ 6.7/10 (114 votes)

Toying Around

S1:E7

It's time for the bakers to create cakes that look like toys. Let the games begin! Guest judges: Brittany Broski, Heidi Gardner and Dan Ahdoot.

★ 7.0/10 (135 votes)

Winner Fakes All!

S1:E8

The top three contenders design the cakes of their dreams for a shot at a $50,000 prize. Guest judges: Loni Love, Bobby Moynihan and Karamo Brown.

KatWaterflame Apr 5, 2022

Yay! The person I hoped would win was the one who won!

Season Average Rating Episodes Best Episode Worst Episode
1 ★ 6.6 8
★ 7.0 Winner Fakes All!
★ 6.0 Fast-Food Fakeout
2 ★ 6.3 8
★ 6.8 Everything Is Cake!
★ 5.1 Cake University
Mikey Day
Cast & Crew

View all 1 cast members and crew