Tell Me Lies poster

Best Episodes Of Tell Me Lies

Overall Rating: ★ 7.0

Best Episodes Of Tell Me Lies

(Overall Rating: ★ 7.0)

Episode Ratings & Analysis

Discover the best and most memorable episodes of Tell Me Lies, from fan favorites to critically acclaimed moments. Explore detailed ratings, episode summaries, and visualize how the show's quality evolved over time.

When Lucy Albright arrives on the campus of her small college, away from her mother whom she's never forgiven for an act of betrayal in her early teen years, Lucy embraces college life and all it has to offer. But everything changes when she meets Stephen DeMarco, who has a mysterious past of his own. Their addicting entanglement will have consequences they never could have imagined.

2 Seasons
18 Episodes
Returning Series
Drama Mystery
Best Episodes
S2E8 - Don't Struggle Like That, Or I Will Only Love You More ★ 8.9
S2E7 - I’m Not Drowning Fast Enough ★ 7.8
S2E6 - Do Your Dirty Words Come Out To Play? ★ 7.7
Worst Episodes
S1E6 - And I'm Sorry If I Dissed You ★ 6.7
S1E1 - Lightning Strikes ★ 6.8
S1E2 - Hot-Blooded ★ 7.0
★ 8.9/10 (339 votes)
#1

Don't Struggle Like That, Or I Will Only Love You More

S2:E8

End of semester Christmas celebrations change everything for everyone - again.

michellecgb Oct 17, 2024

I hate Lucy and Stephen equally. I side-eye anyone who likes her.

★ 7.8/10 (192 votes)
#2

I’m Not Drowning Fast Enough

S2:E7

Lucy and Bree attend a professor's Christmas party. Lucy makes a rash decision that affects Pippa.

lucindanukari Oct 14, 2024

oh and Cat Missal has SUCH GOOD MUSIC

★ 7.7/10 (191 votes)
#3

Do Your Dirty Words Come Out To Play?

S2:E6

When a snowed-in campus forces everyone to Evan’s for Thanksgiving, tensions run high.

michellecgb Oct 3, 2024

This show is a hot mess. I can't stop watching all of these different types of shitty people be mess...

★ 7.6/10 (313 votes)
#4

The Bedrooms Of Our Friends

S1:E10

Lucy and Stephen go to the final party of the semester and everything changes.

★ 7.4/10 (156 votes)
#5

Evil, Ornery, Scandalous, and Evil

S2:E5

Lydia and Stephen’s sister, Sadie, both visit campus for Halloween. Lucy and Pippa learn something unsettling.

lucindanukari Sep 29, 2024

I love Bree and Oliver OH MY GOOOOOD. and Wrigley and Pippa have such a cute friendship!!

★ 7.3/10 (227 votes)
#6

Sugar, We're Going Down Swinging

S1:E9

Things between Wrigley and Drew come to a head. Lucy is forced to confront her past.

BNikolka Oct 21, 2022

How could someone be as stupid as Lucy is? It's annoying.

★ 7.3/10 (193 votes)
#7

I Shall Now Perform a 180 Flip-Flop

S2:E2

Bree’s birthday takes an unexpected turn. Lucy's excited to focus on someone new.

G*ella Jan 13, 2025

The fuck*n chemistry and tension between Bree and the teacher sh*t it's just too damn good And tha...

★ 7.3/10 (169 votes)
#8

I Can See Right Through Myself

S2:E3

Stephen baits Lucy as she attempts to rid herself of him once and for all. Wrigley and Pippa finally talk.

G*ella Jan 13, 2025

Good for ypu Lucy get him out of your life I swear that every girl in this show is just like so du...

★ 7.2/10 (278 votes)
#9

We Don't Touch, We Collide

S1:E3

Pressure on Wrigley intensifies, bleeding into his relationship with Pippa. Lucy and Stephen discuss exclusivity.

jaredisok Oct 7, 2022

EVERYONE HERE IS A GOD DAMN MESS BRO

★ 7.2/10 (236 votes)
#10

Castle on a Cloud

S1:E7

The group goes to Evan's lake house to celebrate his 21st birthday.

BNikolka Oct 11, 2022

Stephen is such a disgusting person. I hate him so much! Evan and Bree are cute. I'm happy to know...

★ 7.2/10 (210 votes)
#11

You Got a Reaction, Didn't You?

S2:E1

Lucy’s back at Baird College for sophomore year, ready to start fresh and leave past mistakes behind her.

BNikolka Oct 8, 2024

So Tom Ellis is here. I think this is not a coincidence. Bree, Bree. Don't be a bad girl! Stephen i...

★ 7.1/10 (249 votes)
#12

Merry F*cking Christmas

S1:E5

Lucy and Stephen go home for winter break and deal with family tension. Meanwhile, Lucy uncovers a secret.

★ 7.0/10 (290 votes)
#13

Hot-Blooded

S1:E2

Lucy struggles with the aftermath of Welcome Week and goes on her first date with Stephen.

★ 7.0/10 (246 votes)
#14

Take Off Your Pants and Jacket

S1:E4

Bree attempts to lose her virginity. Stephen goes to New York City for the weekend, while Lucy tries to figure out where their relationship stands.

jaredisok Oct 9, 2022

EVERYONE HERE IS STRESSING ME OUT

★ 7.0/10 (217 votes)
#15

Don't Go Wasting Your Emotion

S1:E8

Pippa has complicated feelings after Wrigley meets her dad. Lucy makes a decision to protect Stephen.

★ 7.0/10 (154 votes)
#16

Just Stable Children

S2:E4

As the LSAT looms, Stephen’s anxiety grows. Wrigley and Evan have a guy’s night out.

★ 6.8/10 (379 votes)
#17

Lightning Strikes

S1:E1

Lucy starts her freshman year at Baird College, where an unexpected turn of events during Welcome Week flips her life upside down.

Kyria Crosszeria Nov 27, 2023

Oh. Anyone else feeling generally left cold in the heart, but know a Steve in their life? 🙃 This t...

★ 6.7/10 (229 votes)
#18

And I'm Sorry If I Dissed You

S1:E6

Lucy confronts Stephen about what she found at Macy's memorial.

BNikolka Sep 30, 2022

Stephen is one of the most disgusting guy I've ever seen on TV.

★ 6.7/10 (229 votes)
#1

And I'm Sorry If I Dissed You

S1:E6

Lucy confronts Stephen about what she found at Macy's memorial.

BNikolka Sep 30, 2022

Stephen is one of the most disgusting guy I've ever seen on TV.

★ 6.8/10 (379 votes)
#2

Lightning Strikes

S1:E1

Lucy starts her freshman year at Baird College, where an unexpected turn of events during Welcome Week flips her life upside down.

Kyria Crosszeria Nov 27, 2023

Oh. Anyone else feeling generally left cold in the heart, but know a Steve in their life? 🙃 This t...

★ 7.0/10 (290 votes)
#3

Hot-Blooded

S1:E2

Lucy struggles with the aftermath of Welcome Week and goes on her first date with Stephen.

★ 7.0/10 (246 votes)
#4

Take Off Your Pants and Jacket

S1:E4

Bree attempts to lose her virginity. Stephen goes to New York City for the weekend, while Lucy tries to figure out where their relationship stands.

jaredisok Oct 9, 2022

EVERYONE HERE IS STRESSING ME OUT

★ 7.0/10 (217 votes)
#5

Don't Go Wasting Your Emotion

S1:E8

Pippa has complicated feelings after Wrigley meets her dad. Lucy makes a decision to protect Stephen.

★ 7.0/10 (154 votes)
#6

Just Stable Children

S2:E4

As the LSAT looms, Stephen’s anxiety grows. Wrigley and Evan have a guy’s night out.

★ 7.1/10 (249 votes)
#7

Merry F*cking Christmas

S1:E5

Lucy and Stephen go home for winter break and deal with family tension. Meanwhile, Lucy uncovers a secret.

★ 7.2/10 (278 votes)
#8

We Don't Touch, We Collide

S1:E3

Pressure on Wrigley intensifies, bleeding into his relationship with Pippa. Lucy and Stephen discuss exclusivity.

jaredisok Oct 7, 2022

EVERYONE HERE IS A GOD DAMN MESS BRO

★ 7.2/10 (236 votes)
#9

Castle on a Cloud

S1:E7

The group goes to Evan's lake house to celebrate his 21st birthday.

BNikolka Oct 11, 2022

Stephen is such a disgusting person. I hate him so much! Evan and Bree are cute. I'm happy to know...

★ 7.2/10 (210 votes)
#10

You Got a Reaction, Didn't You?

S2:E1

Lucy’s back at Baird College for sophomore year, ready to start fresh and leave past mistakes behind her.

BNikolka Oct 8, 2024

So Tom Ellis is here. I think this is not a coincidence. Bree, Bree. Don't be a bad girl! Stephen i...

★ 7.3/10 (227 votes)
#11

Sugar, We're Going Down Swinging

S1:E9

Things between Wrigley and Drew come to a head. Lucy is forced to confront her past.

BNikolka Oct 21, 2022

How could someone be as stupid as Lucy is? It's annoying.

★ 7.3/10 (193 votes)
#12

I Shall Now Perform a 180 Flip-Flop

S2:E2

Bree’s birthday takes an unexpected turn. Lucy's excited to focus on someone new.

G*ella Jan 13, 2025

The fuck*n chemistry and tension between Bree and the teacher sh*t it's just too damn good And tha...

★ 7.3/10 (169 votes)
#13

I Can See Right Through Myself

S2:E3

Stephen baits Lucy as she attempts to rid herself of him once and for all. Wrigley and Pippa finally talk.

G*ella Jan 13, 2025

Good for ypu Lucy get him out of your life I swear that every girl in this show is just like so du...

★ 7.4/10 (156 votes)
#14

Evil, Ornery, Scandalous, and Evil

S2:E5

Lydia and Stephen’s sister, Sadie, both visit campus for Halloween. Lucy and Pippa learn something unsettling.

lucindanukari Sep 29, 2024

I love Bree and Oliver OH MY GOOOOOD. and Wrigley and Pippa have such a cute friendship!!

★ 7.6/10 (313 votes)
#15

The Bedrooms Of Our Friends

S1:E10

Lucy and Stephen go to the final party of the semester and everything changes.

★ 7.7/10 (191 votes)
#16

Do Your Dirty Words Come Out To Play?

S2:E6

When a snowed-in campus forces everyone to Evan’s for Thanksgiving, tensions run high.

michellecgb Oct 3, 2024

This show is a hot mess. I can't stop watching all of these different types of shitty people be mess...

★ 7.8/10 (192 votes)
#17

I’m Not Drowning Fast Enough

S2:E7

Lucy and Bree attend a professor's Christmas party. Lucy makes a rash decision that affects Pippa.

lucindanukari Oct 14, 2024

oh and Cat Missal has SUCH GOOD MUSIC

★ 8.9/10 (339 votes)
#18

Don't Struggle Like That, Or I Will Only Love You More

S2:E8

End of semester Christmas celebrations change everything for everyone - again.

michellecgb Oct 17, 2024

I hate Lucy and Stephen equally. I side-eye anyone who likes her.

★ 6.8/10 (379 votes)

Lightning Strikes

S1:E1

Lucy starts her freshman year at Baird College, where an unexpected turn of events during Welcome Week flips her life upside down.

Kyria Crosszeria Nov 27, 2023

Oh. Anyone else feeling generally left cold in the heart, but know a Steve in their life? 🙃 This t...

★ 7.0/10 (290 votes)

Hot-Blooded

S1:E2

Lucy struggles with the aftermath of Welcome Week and goes on her first date with Stephen.

★ 7.2/10 (278 votes)

We Don't Touch, We Collide

S1:E3

Pressure on Wrigley intensifies, bleeding into his relationship with Pippa. Lucy and Stephen discuss exclusivity.

jaredisok Oct 7, 2022

EVERYONE HERE IS A GOD DAMN MESS BRO

★ 7.0/10 (246 votes)

Take Off Your Pants and Jacket

S1:E4

Bree attempts to lose her virginity. Stephen goes to New York City for the weekend, while Lucy tries to figure out where their relationship stands.

jaredisok Oct 9, 2022

EVERYONE HERE IS STRESSING ME OUT

★ 7.1/10 (249 votes)

Merry F*cking Christmas

S1:E5

Lucy and Stephen go home for winter break and deal with family tension. Meanwhile, Lucy uncovers a secret.

★ 6.7/10 (229 votes)

And I'm Sorry If I Dissed You

S1:E6

Lucy confronts Stephen about what she found at Macy's memorial.

BNikolka Sep 30, 2022

Stephen is one of the most disgusting guy I've ever seen on TV.

★ 7.2/10 (236 votes)

Castle on a Cloud

S1:E7

The group goes to Evan's lake house to celebrate his 21st birthday.

BNikolka Oct 11, 2022

Stephen is such a disgusting person. I hate him so much! Evan and Bree are cute. I'm happy to know...

★ 7.0/10 (217 votes)

Don't Go Wasting Your Emotion

S1:E8

Pippa has complicated feelings after Wrigley meets her dad. Lucy makes a decision to protect Stephen.

★ 7.3/10 (227 votes)

Sugar, We're Going Down Swinging

S1:E9

Things between Wrigley and Drew come to a head. Lucy is forced to confront her past.

BNikolka Oct 21, 2022

How could someone be as stupid as Lucy is? It's annoying.

★ 7.6/10 (313 votes)

The Bedrooms Of Our Friends

S1:E10

Lucy and Stephen go to the final party of the semester and everything changes.

★ 7.2/10 (210 votes)

You Got a Reaction, Didn't You?

S2:E1

Lucy’s back at Baird College for sophomore year, ready to start fresh and leave past mistakes behind her.

BNikolka Oct 8, 2024

So Tom Ellis is here. I think this is not a coincidence. Bree, Bree. Don't be a bad girl! Stephen i...

★ 7.3/10 (193 votes)

I Shall Now Perform a 180 Flip-Flop

S2:E2

Bree’s birthday takes an unexpected turn. Lucy's excited to focus on someone new.

G*ella Jan 13, 2025

The fuck*n chemistry and tension between Bree and the teacher sh*t it's just too damn good And tha...

★ 7.3/10 (169 votes)

I Can See Right Through Myself

S2:E3

Stephen baits Lucy as she attempts to rid herself of him once and for all. Wrigley and Pippa finally talk.

G*ella Jan 13, 2025

Good for ypu Lucy get him out of your life I swear that every girl in this show is just like so du...

★ 7.0/10 (154 votes)

Just Stable Children

S2:E4

As the LSAT looms, Stephen’s anxiety grows. Wrigley and Evan have a guy’s night out.

★ 7.4/10 (156 votes)

Evil, Ornery, Scandalous, and Evil

S2:E5

Lydia and Stephen’s sister, Sadie, both visit campus for Halloween. Lucy and Pippa learn something unsettling.

lucindanukari Sep 29, 2024

I love Bree and Oliver OH MY GOOOOOD. and Wrigley and Pippa have such a cute friendship!!

★ 7.7/10 (191 votes)

Do Your Dirty Words Come Out To Play?

S2:E6

When a snowed-in campus forces everyone to Evan’s for Thanksgiving, tensions run high.

michellecgb Oct 3, 2024

This show is a hot mess. I can't stop watching all of these different types of shitty people be mess...

★ 7.8/10 (192 votes)

I’m Not Drowning Fast Enough

S2:E7

Lucy and Bree attend a professor's Christmas party. Lucy makes a rash decision that affects Pippa.

lucindanukari Oct 14, 2024

oh and Cat Missal has SUCH GOOD MUSIC

★ 8.9/10 (339 votes)

Don't Struggle Like That, Or I Will Only Love You More

S2:E8

End of semester Christmas celebrations change everything for everyone - again.

michellecgb Oct 17, 2024

I hate Lucy and Stephen equally. I side-eye anyone who likes her.

Season Average Rating Episodes Best Episode Worst Episode
2 ★ 7.6 8
★ 8.9 Don't Struggle Like That, Or I Will Only Love You More
★ 7.0 Just Stable Children
1 ★ 7.1 10
★ 7.6 The Bedrooms Of Our Friends
★ 6.7 And I'm Sorry If I Dissed You
Grace Van Patten
Jackson White
Catherine Missal
A
+2
Cast & Crew

View all 6 cast members and crew