Based on a True Story poster

Best Episodes Of Based on a True Story

Overall Rating: ★ 7.2

Best Episodes Of Based on a True Story

(Overall Rating: ★ 7.2)

Episode Ratings & Analysis

Discover the best and most memorable episodes of Based on a True Story, from fan favorites to critically acclaimed moments. Explore detailed ratings, episode summaries, and visualize how the show's quality evolved over time.

The lives of a realtor, a plumber and a former tennis star unexpectedly collide, exposing America’s obsession with true crime, murder and the slow-close toilet seat.

2 Seasons
16 Episodes
Returning Series
Comedy Drama
Best Episodes
S2E6 - Based on a Drew Story ★ 8.0
S2E7 - Shotgun Wedding ★ 8.0
S2E8 - This Week's Guest ★ 7.8
Worst Episodes
S2E1 - Liquid Gold ★ 7.0
S1E8 - The Universe ★ 7.1
S1E1 - The Great American Art Form ★ 7.3
★ 8.0/10 (166 votes)
#1

Based on a Drew Story

S2:E6

Ava and Nathan look for Drew; Matt and Tory plan their wedding, but he gives into his dark desires.

★ 8.0/10 (166 votes)
#2

Shotgun Wedding

S2:E7

Matt's past comes back to haunt Ava and Nathan; Ava realizes her obsession has become an addiction.

★ 7.8/10 (181 votes)
#3

This Week's Guest

S2:E8

Ava and Nathan are on a game show with deadly stakes; Tory and Matt are on the run from the police.

007alex Nov 22, 2024

Didn't expect that, Still a great show.

★ 7.7/10 (575 votes)
#4

The Survivor

S1:E4

Ava, Nathan and Matt attend a true crime convention; a surprise panelist threatens the podcast.

aars26 Mar 3, 2024

Another way this could’ve went so they weren’t accomplices to a crime was that Matt was forcing the...

★ 7.6/10 (163 votes)
#5

Double Fault

S2:E5

Nathan plays a redemption match; Ava and Matt decode a cipher from the new killer haunting LA.

great_vc Dec 7, 2024

I knew something was up but not that. Great twist, nice season so far, better than the first I think...

★ 7.5/10 (565 votes)
#6

Ted Bundy Bottle Opener

S1:E5

After a shocking incident at CrimeCon, Ava and Nathan probe Matt for the truth.

aars26 Mar 4, 2024

Was that Claire from the vampire dairies? Love her!

★ 7.5/10 (564 votes)
#7

Love You, Buzzfeed

S1:E6

Ava and Nathan attend a charity auction at Ruby's mansion, where new and old wounds are laid bare.

demeter Apr 15, 2024

Give the dog an Emmy!!!

★ 7.5/10 (163 votes)
#8

Relapse

S2:E3

Ava investigates a crime scene and runs into an old friend; Nathan takes a risk seeking redemption.

★ 7.5/10 (159 votes)
#9

Y'all Ready for This?

S2:E4

Ava and Nathan go to a sex party to rekindle their spark; Matt is confronted by a fellow addict.

Cyn.C Nov 22, 2024

This season seems better than the first

★ 7.4/10 (568 votes)
#10

Who's Next?

S1:E3

Ava and Nathan spar with Matt for creative control; Nathan struggles to keep his story straight.

Hreeterne Nov 22, 2024

Omg you guys why do I like the serial killer?? 😂 He is so funny I can't deal. the actor is amazing ...

★ 7.4/10 (182 votes)
#11

Control F for Murder

S2:E2

Ava tries to make new friends but gets interrogated; Matt helps Nathan stand up for himself.

007alex Nov 21, 2024

I suspected that she would be a cop. 99 Forever !

★ 7.3/10 (726 votes)
#12

The Great American Art Form

S1:E1

A realtor and a former tennis star struggle to stay afloat as a serial killer puts LA on alert.

great_vc Jun 10, 2023

Nice pilot, interesting approach, please do not compare it with "only murder in the building" lets ...

★ 7.3/10 (604 votes)
#13

BDE

S1:E2

Ava and Nathan try to maintain appearances; detectives question Nathan at work; Matt asks to meet.

Hreeterne Nov 22, 2024

Super obvious meh, but it was actually still fun. I loved the scene with their friends, anyone would...

★ 7.3/10 (508 votes)
#14

National Geographic

S1:E7

Nathan reckons with a devastating failure; Ava confronts her buyer; Matt takes a new approach.

anikatalia Dec 19, 2024

I'm sorry but the amount of fantasized adultery in this showed ruins everything and frankly the only...

★ 7.1/10 (551 votes)
#15

The Universe

S1:E8

With the cards finally on the table, Ava and Nathan race against time to prevent a tragedy.

cutecruel Jun 12, 2023

Just watched all 8 episodes in one sitting. I enjoyed the first half of this eight-episode seaso...

★ 7.0/10 (216 votes)
#16

Liquid Gold

S2:E1

Ava and Nathan struggle with parenthood and try to convince Matt to return home.

cutecruel Nov 22, 2024

* Tory being so cool with Matt being a murderer is wild. * I don't know whether to be surprised o...

★ 7.0/10 (216 votes)
#1

Liquid Gold

S2:E1

Ava and Nathan struggle with parenthood and try to convince Matt to return home.

cutecruel Nov 22, 2024

* Tory being so cool with Matt being a murderer is wild. * I don't know whether to be surprised o...

★ 7.1/10 (551 votes)
#2

The Universe

S1:E8

With the cards finally on the table, Ava and Nathan race against time to prevent a tragedy.

cutecruel Jun 12, 2023

Just watched all 8 episodes in one sitting. I enjoyed the first half of this eight-episode seaso...

★ 7.3/10 (726 votes)
#3

The Great American Art Form

S1:E1

A realtor and a former tennis star struggle to stay afloat as a serial killer puts LA on alert.

great_vc Jun 10, 2023

Nice pilot, interesting approach, please do not compare it with "only murder in the building" lets ...

★ 7.3/10 (604 votes)
#4

BDE

S1:E2

Ava and Nathan try to maintain appearances; detectives question Nathan at work; Matt asks to meet.

Hreeterne Nov 22, 2024

Super obvious meh, but it was actually still fun. I loved the scene with their friends, anyone would...

★ 7.3/10 (508 votes)
#5

National Geographic

S1:E7

Nathan reckons with a devastating failure; Ava confronts her buyer; Matt takes a new approach.

anikatalia Dec 19, 2024

I'm sorry but the amount of fantasized adultery in this showed ruins everything and frankly the only...

★ 7.4/10 (568 votes)
#6

Who's Next?

S1:E3

Ava and Nathan spar with Matt for creative control; Nathan struggles to keep his story straight.

Hreeterne Nov 22, 2024

Omg you guys why do I like the serial killer?? 😂 He is so funny I can't deal. the actor is amazing ...

★ 7.4/10 (182 votes)
#7

Control F for Murder

S2:E2

Ava tries to make new friends but gets interrogated; Matt helps Nathan stand up for himself.

007alex Nov 21, 2024

I suspected that she would be a cop. 99 Forever !

★ 7.5/10 (565 votes)
#8

Ted Bundy Bottle Opener

S1:E5

After a shocking incident at CrimeCon, Ava and Nathan probe Matt for the truth.

aars26 Mar 4, 2024

Was that Claire from the vampire dairies? Love her!

★ 7.5/10 (564 votes)
#9

Love You, Buzzfeed

S1:E6

Ava and Nathan attend a charity auction at Ruby's mansion, where new and old wounds are laid bare.

demeter Apr 15, 2024

Give the dog an Emmy!!!

★ 7.5/10 (163 votes)
#10

Relapse

S2:E3

Ava investigates a crime scene and runs into an old friend; Nathan takes a risk seeking redemption.

★ 7.5/10 (159 votes)
#11

Y'all Ready for This?

S2:E4

Ava and Nathan go to a sex party to rekindle their spark; Matt is confronted by a fellow addict.

Cyn.C Nov 22, 2024

This season seems better than the first

★ 7.6/10 (163 votes)
#12

Double Fault

S2:E5

Nathan plays a redemption match; Ava and Matt decode a cipher from the new killer haunting LA.

great_vc Dec 7, 2024

I knew something was up but not that. Great twist, nice season so far, better than the first I think...

★ 7.7/10 (575 votes)
#13

The Survivor

S1:E4

Ava, Nathan and Matt attend a true crime convention; a surprise panelist threatens the podcast.

aars26 Mar 3, 2024

Another way this could’ve went so they weren’t accomplices to a crime was that Matt was forcing the...

★ 7.8/10 (181 votes)
#14

This Week's Guest

S2:E8

Ava and Nathan are on a game show with deadly stakes; Tory and Matt are on the run from the police.

007alex Nov 22, 2024

Didn't expect that, Still a great show.

★ 8.0/10 (166 votes)
#15

Based on a Drew Story

S2:E6

Ava and Nathan look for Drew; Matt and Tory plan their wedding, but he gives into his dark desires.

★ 8.0/10 (166 votes)
#16

Shotgun Wedding

S2:E7

Matt's past comes back to haunt Ava and Nathan; Ava realizes her obsession has become an addiction.

★ 7.3/10 (726 votes)

The Great American Art Form

S1:E1

A realtor and a former tennis star struggle to stay afloat as a serial killer puts LA on alert.

great_vc Jun 10, 2023

Nice pilot, interesting approach, please do not compare it with "only murder in the building" lets ...

★ 7.3/10 (604 votes)

BDE

S1:E2

Ava and Nathan try to maintain appearances; detectives question Nathan at work; Matt asks to meet.

Hreeterne Nov 22, 2024

Super obvious meh, but it was actually still fun. I loved the scene with their friends, anyone would...

★ 7.4/10 (568 votes)

Who's Next?

S1:E3

Ava and Nathan spar with Matt for creative control; Nathan struggles to keep his story straight.

Hreeterne Nov 22, 2024

Omg you guys why do I like the serial killer?? 😂 He is so funny I can't deal. the actor is amazing ...

★ 7.7/10 (575 votes)

The Survivor

S1:E4

Ava, Nathan and Matt attend a true crime convention; a surprise panelist threatens the podcast.

aars26 Mar 3, 2024

Another way this could’ve went so they weren’t accomplices to a crime was that Matt was forcing the...

★ 7.5/10 (565 votes)

Ted Bundy Bottle Opener

S1:E5

After a shocking incident at CrimeCon, Ava and Nathan probe Matt for the truth.

aars26 Mar 4, 2024

Was that Claire from the vampire dairies? Love her!

★ 7.5/10 (564 votes)

Love You, Buzzfeed

S1:E6

Ava and Nathan attend a charity auction at Ruby's mansion, where new and old wounds are laid bare.

demeter Apr 15, 2024

Give the dog an Emmy!!!

★ 7.3/10 (508 votes)

National Geographic

S1:E7

Nathan reckons with a devastating failure; Ava confronts her buyer; Matt takes a new approach.

anikatalia Dec 19, 2024

I'm sorry but the amount of fantasized adultery in this showed ruins everything and frankly the only...

★ 7.1/10 (551 votes)

The Universe

S1:E8

With the cards finally on the table, Ava and Nathan race against time to prevent a tragedy.

cutecruel Jun 12, 2023

Just watched all 8 episodes in one sitting. I enjoyed the first half of this eight-episode seaso...

★ 7.0/10 (216 votes)

Liquid Gold

S2:E1

Ava and Nathan struggle with parenthood and try to convince Matt to return home.

cutecruel Nov 22, 2024

* Tory being so cool with Matt being a murderer is wild. * I don't know whether to be surprised o...

★ 7.4/10 (182 votes)

Control F for Murder

S2:E2

Ava tries to make new friends but gets interrogated; Matt helps Nathan stand up for himself.

007alex Nov 21, 2024

I suspected that she would be a cop. 99 Forever !

★ 7.5/10 (163 votes)

Relapse

S2:E3

Ava investigates a crime scene and runs into an old friend; Nathan takes a risk seeking redemption.

★ 7.5/10 (159 votes)

Y'all Ready for This?

S2:E4

Ava and Nathan go to a sex party to rekindle their spark; Matt is confronted by a fellow addict.

Cyn.C Nov 22, 2024

This season seems better than the first

★ 7.6/10 (163 votes)

Double Fault

S2:E5

Nathan plays a redemption match; Ava and Matt decode a cipher from the new killer haunting LA.

great_vc Dec 7, 2024

I knew something was up but not that. Great twist, nice season so far, better than the first I think...

★ 8.0/10 (166 votes)

Based on a Drew Story

S2:E6

Ava and Nathan look for Drew; Matt and Tory plan their wedding, but he gives into his dark desires.

★ 8.0/10 (166 votes)

Shotgun Wedding

S2:E7

Matt's past comes back to haunt Ava and Nathan; Ava realizes her obsession has become an addiction.

★ 7.8/10 (181 votes)

This Week's Guest

S2:E8

Ava and Nathan are on a game show with deadly stakes; Tory and Matt are on the run from the police.

007alex Nov 22, 2024

Didn't expect that, Still a great show.

Season Average Rating Episodes Best Episode Worst Episode
2 ★ 7.6 8
★ 8.0 Based on a Drew Story
★ 7.0 Liquid Gold
1 ★ 7.4 8
★ 7.7 The Survivor
★ 7.1 The Universe
Kaley Cuoco
Chris Messina
Tom Bateman
Liana Liberato
Cast & Crew

View all 4 cast members and crew